A Simple Favor (2019) [Blu-ray]
Comedy | Crime | Drama | Mystery | Thriller

Tagline: What Happened to Emily?

Stephanie is a single mother with a parenting vlog who befriends Emily, a secretive upper-class woman who has a child at the same elementary school. When Emily goes missing, Stephanie takes it upon herself to investigate. Stephanie is joined by Emily's husband Sean in this stylish thriller filled with twists and betrayals, secrets and revelations, love and loyalty, murder and revenge.

Storyline: Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick) is a widowed single mother who runs a blog with crafts and recipes. Emily (Blake Lively) is a busy working mother, a PR director for a fashion company, whose son Nicky attends the same elementary school as Stephanie's son, Miles. Emily and Stephanie become fast friends, arranging play dates for the boys. They trade confessions, and Stephanie admits that as a teenager, she had sex with her half-brother, Chris. Emily expresses her frustration at the lack of success of her husband, English professor Sean Townsend, and their poor financial situation. Emily has a work crisis and asks Stephanie to babysit Nicky, as Sean is in London. After two days of Emily not responding to calls, Stephanie calls Emily's employer, Dennis Nylon, and he tells her she is in Miami. Stephanie calls Sean, who calls the police. Emily had told both Stephanie and Sean that she hates having her picture taken, leading Stephanie to sneak into Emily's work and find a photo, which she uses to create missing person posters.

Reviewer's Note: Reviewed by Jeffrey Kauffman, December 21, 2018 Back in the days of print media, those of us who worked as reviewers at newspapers and/or magazines knew we were probably dealing with a less than completely successful film release if we weren't granted an opportunity to see the film before its general public exhibition. The thinking by the studios seemed to be, "The less said, the better", in the case of some "questionable" properties. One might think that that same kind of "caution" wouldn't necessarily extend to the home media market, since, after all, for all but direct to video releases, movies and television outings being put out on various home media platforms including 1080p Blu-ray and 4K UHD discs have more than likely already been reviewed and, perhaps more importantly, have certainly either been given approval or dismissal by paying audiences. And yet Lionsgate kind of strangely didn't provide a review copy of A Simple Favor (to me, anyway), this despite the fact that the film's theatrical exhibition was largely met with positive reviews and (again, perhaps more importantly) at least decent box office returns. However, after having now watched the film and come away at least a little surprised by the tone of it all, I have to say Lionsgate's marketing "strategy" for this film as a whole seems almost willfully boneheaded. The promotional trailers I saw on broadcast and cable television trying to drum up business for the film's theatrical exhibition made A Simple Favor seem like "Gone Girl redux". While there is a missing persons element to A Simple Favor, the trailers I personally saw pretty much completely missed the fact that this outing is considerably cheekier than the Gillian Flynn adaptation, with a dark but potent sense of humor, as perhaps might have been surmised by anyone paying attention to the fact that Paul Feig co-produced and directed it.

Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick) runs a "mommy vlog" devoted to recipes and crafting, but she takes time out from her "duties" to thank her viewers for being so responsive to a recent event in Stephanie's life — the mysterious disappearance of her best friend Emily Nelson (Blake Lively). The film then backtracks to depict the meeting of these two, who ended up bonding, more or less anyway, after their adorable sons asked for a playdate when the moms were picking them up at the school both kids attend. Emily is a fashionista, a total Type A with a more than generous amount of snark at her command, while Stephanie is kind of mousy and meek, and so the two would seem to be like oil and water, but perhaps because Stephanie is so taken with Emily and what is revealed to be her incredibly opulent lifestyle, a "kinda sorta" friendship is forged, even if some of the other parents in the "moms' club" at the school are convinced the "friendship" is merely Emily's ploy to get Stephanie to be a nanny without pay.

Histories of both Stephanie and Emily are kind of doled out piecemeal as the two get to know each other, but once Emily doesn't return after giving Stephanie a rushed call that she has an emergency at work and Stephanie needs to pick up Emily's son after school, Stephanie begins poking her nose around in areas where she arguably shouldn't, ultimately kind of taking Emily's place at the Nelson home, which includes author husband Sean Townsend (Henry Golding) and that aforementioned adorable little boy, Nicky (Ian Ho). Already scenarist Jessica Sharzer is toying with audience expectations, since it seems awfully "coincidental" that Emily should disappear so conveniently, allowing Stephanie to get a taste of a life she'd heretofore only dreamed about. Stephanie soon discovers that Emily had any number of secrets, and it's already been revealed that Emily has an absolute abhorrence to having her picture taken, so there are hints that Emily may either be on the lam or hiding her "true identity" for one reason or the other. It also turns out that Stephanie is not the "saint" that everyone seems to think she is.

Since this film engages in absolutely gleeful misdirection until virtually the last moment, it's no huge spoiler to state that Emily ends up dead in a lake in Michigan, which sends Stephanie into an investigative fury, all documented interstitially on her vlog. Romantic escapades with Sean have also ensued, making things more complicated, but the police, notably a detective named Summerhill (Bashir Salahuddin) seems to be at least a couple of steps ahead of Stephanie at several key junctures. A Simple Favor can't help but exploit a conceit very similar to that employed in Gone Girl, with a mid-story reveal and subsequent slight change of perspective, at which point the plot becomes increasingly far fetched, though the pace is so brisk and the performances so energetic that suspension of disbelief isn't a major problem.

Still, there are a couple of odd elisions here that make it feel like things may have been rejiggered at some point. By the time Stephanie is exploring the nooks and crannies of what seems to be a Christian day camp for teenagers, and then has a run in with Emily's mother Margaret (Jean Smart) and a completely unexplained character named Bruce (Roger Dunn), things may teeter precariously close to going off the edge for some viewers. Other characters, like Emily's fashion icon boss Dennis Nylon (Rupert Friend) and the sole male member of the school's moms' club Darren (Andrew Rannells) are never really developed and are frankly utilized mostly to deliver occasional punchlines more than anything. There's also a completely underdeveloped character who seems to be having (another) affair with Sean, and several plot points, including the mysterious reappearance of all of Emily's clothes after Stephanie gets rid of them, and a brief allusion to some lesbian activity by the women, are just kind of plopped down with little or no context, as if at least some parts of the film ended up on the cutting room floor.

There's an undeniably arch quality to much of A Simple Favor which may not be everyone's cup of tea, but there's some really, well, lively interplay between Lively and Kendrick which keeps the energy here crackling almost all of the time. The labyrinthine screenplay also has enough sense to make fun of itself (at one point Stephanie asks Sean if he and Emily are "Diabolique-ing" her), with a hyperbolic climax that delivers a series of twists and a fair amount of hilarity.

Note: My colleague Brian Orndorf was considerably less pleased with the film than I was. You can read Brian's thoughts here.

Despite its sometimes head scratching omissions and/or lack of logic, I actually enjoyed huge swaths of A Simple Favor. The film made me laugh out loud several times, and the interplay between Kendrick and Lively was consistently engaging. The film may offer just a few too many ostensible twists for its own good, but it seems to have a sense of humor about itself, something that is often sadly missing in contemporary comedies. Fans of the cast will most likely be willing to overlook any perceived deficits. Technical merits are first rate, the supplemental package outstanding, and A Simple Favor comes Recommended.

[CSW] -4.2- This movie will get mixed reviews. For those like me that liked the comedy drama mix, it will get high marks. For those who don't, they will find the mix confusing. This movie has a clever plot with some nifty twists but it takes a while to get going. This had the effect of lowering my expectations, which was actually a good thing as the plot twists began to take hold. Although the ending was a tiny bit predictable, I enjoyed it none the less. In the end I would have gladly have been her one millionth blog viewer, although I'm not so sure that I would have ever hired her as a private investigator.
[V4.5-A4.5] MPEG-4 AVC - No D-Box


º º